Round One: The Presenters
Top Gear: The Top Gear presenter entourage consisted of Jeremy Clarkson, James May and Richard Hammond. All members of the presentation team are male and it is clear that the show is mostly aimed towards a male audience. The three have a strong friend like relationship which translates across well on screen and relates to its target audience in a jokey colloquial manner. This manner helps create lasting memories in their audience often finding people referring to specific lines used by the presenters. Although they do a good job at avoiding revealing the fact, it is apparent that a lot of their discussion are scripted beforehand.
Score: 9/10
Loose Women: The Loose Women show currently consists of four predominant anchors; Kaye Adams, Ruth Langsford and Andrea McLean and an additional rotating panellist from show to show. The ladies all have a similar colloquial mannerism to one another but don’t engage in the ‘boyish’ banter that the Top Gear team do. They instead aim to appeal to ladies as the title suggests by occasionally engaging one another in gossip and jokes. There discussions feel much less scripted and free however their discussions don’t create lasting impressions on its audience. The rotating cast also means that a particular cast member a viewer enjoys could not feature in the next show and potentially loose fan base, but also new presenters to the show could have an opposite effect.
Score: 7/10
Round Two: The Look
Top Gear: The set design of the Top Gear show is situated in an open warehouse type environment and filled with cars and various car paraphernalia, from old run down cars to car seats and an engine coffee table. The whole show is very centrally themed on cars and establishes exactly what this show is about from the get go. Its opening graphics of the spinning axel and the title Top Gear also reinforces the car theme. The shows theme tune is snazzy and upbeat with a quick pace to it, again matching the theme of racing cars. The set is quite minimalist however and there is little colour thrown in, perhaps as a method of appealing to a male audience.
Score: 7/10
Loose Women: The set design for the Loose Women, like its presenter entourage, changes from season to season so i’ll be looking at its most recent incarnation. Their set is also quite minimalist but makes use of vivid popping colours to draw in its viewers. This I feel draws in the female audience it is intended for and creates a ‘modern woman’ feel, as does the dress code of its presenters and guests. The theme of the show is more broad and generally aims at what a female audience might find appealing and as such doesn’t have niche items like Top Gear does.
Score: 8/10
Round Three: The Content
Top Gear: The content of Top Gear is spelled out from the very start of the credits: Cars. And yet, it manages to appeal to a much wider audience than simply car enthusiasts through various funny challenges and special star guests. I personally find Top Gear more interesting of a show then the Loose Women and I am not a car enthusiast at all, yet as a male I think it appeals to me for many of the reasons mentioned before. One piece of content that I feel Top Gear could have benefited from would be more interaction with its audience perhaps in the form of voting or tweet suggestions for challenges.
Score: 9/10
Loose Women: The Loose Women show covers a much broader and topical approach to its show than Top Gear does, creating an interesting variations of stories each week compared to Top Gears singular approach. I personally find the stories discussed on Loose Women to be of little interest to me with a major focus on celebrity gossip and weekly relevant news stories. This is not surprising as the show simply isn’t aimed at me. I feel like the show could benefit from a more permanent presenter group with a different star guest to mix it up from week to week.
Score: 7/10